Finance, Accounting & Legal AI Eval practice drill
10 scenarios, graded as you go, with the exact grading principle for every answer. Start free, no sign-up.
Sample scenarios
PROMPT
Explain whether a manufacturing company with $40M in EBITDA has $40M in free cash available to pay dividends.
MODEL A
Yes—EBITDA strips out non-cash depreciation and amortization, so $40M in EBITDA equals $40M in free cash available for shareholders.
MODEL B
No—EBITDA ignores cash taxes, interest payments, capital expenditures, and working-capital outflows, so actual free cash flow can be far lower than $40M.
Which specialist audit finding best evaluates these responses?
Model A is right because adding back D&A converts operating income directly into distributable free cash flow.
Model B is right: Model A conflates EBITDA with Free Cash Flow by omitting CapEx, taxes, interest, and NWC.
Both models fail because EBITDA already deducts maintenance CapEx and cash income taxes before operating margin.
Model A is better for capital-intensive manufacturers because GAAP requires dividends to be funded directly from EBITDA.
Show the answer
B. Model B is right: Model A conflates EBITDA with Free Cash Flow by omitting CapEx, taxes, interest, and NWC.
EBITDA is an operating proxy, not cash flow. Treating EBITDA as distributable cash ignores capital expenditures, cash taxes, debt service, and working-capital needs—a classic finance RLHF error.
Principle: Corporate Finance Audit: EBITDA vs. Free Cash Flow
SOURCE TEXT
(10-K Note 9, Debt) 'The Company maintains a $250M revolving credit facility maturing in March 2028. As of December 31, 2025, $85M was drawn and $165M remained available, subject to a maximum consolidated leverage ratio of 3.50x.'
AI SUMMARY
The company currently owes $250M on its revolver, which matures in March 2027 under a 3.50x covenant.
Which groundedness audit verdict is accurate?
Pass with minor style feedback: the AI captured the 3.50x leverage covenant and total facility size accurately.
Acceptable financial conservatism: credit analysts routinely treat total facility capacity as fully drawn debt.
Only a date typo: quoting $250M drawn is defensible because the footnote lists $250M as the headline facility figure.
Major groundedness failure: the AI misstated both the drawn balance ($85M, not $250M) and maturity (March 2028, not 2027).
Show the answer
D. Major groundedness failure: the AI misstated both the drawn balance ($85M, not $250M) and maturity (March 2028, not 2027).
Conflating total facility capacity ($250M) with actual drawn debt ($85M) overstates debt by $165M, and fabricating a March 2027 maturity contradicts Note 9's March 2028 date—both are severe 10-K groundedness failures.
In a period of steadily rising raw-material prices and stable inventory volumes, how does using LIFO instead of FIFO affect a US GAAP filer's financial statements?
AI CLAIM
Under rising prices, LIFO expenses the oldest, cheapest units first—lowering COGS and boosting reported net income and ending inventory.
What conceptual error did the AI make?
LIFO is strictly forbidden under US GAAP, so the entire comparison applies only to IFRS filers.
The AI reversed LIFO and FIFO: in rising prices, LIFO yields higher COGS, lower net income, and lower ending inventory.
Inventory method changes affect only the balance sheet; COGS and net income remain identical under LIFO and FIFO.
LIFO yields higher COGS and lower ending inventory, which increases cash income taxes paid to the IRS.
Show the answer
B. The AI reversed LIFO and FIFO: in rising prices, LIFO yields higher COGS, lower net income, and lower ending inventory.
Last-In, First-Out (LIFO) assigns the newest, highest-cost purchases to COGS during inflation. That raises COGS, lowers reported pre-tax and net income, reduces cash taxes, and leaves older, lower-cost inventory on the balance sheet.
Principle: Accounting Audit: LIFO vs. FIFO Under Inflation