Where is the first error in the AI's chain of thought?
Step 1: 2(x + 5) is 2x + 5.
Step 2: adding 7 to both sides gives 10 + 7 = 17, not 10 - 7.
Step 3: 3x - 2x is 5x.
There is no error.
Show the answer
B. Step 2: adding 7 to both sides gives 10 + 7 = 17, not 10 - 7.
To move `-7` from the left side to the right side, you add `7` to both sides: `x = 10 + 7 = 17`. Checking `3(17) - 7 = 44` and `2(17 + 5) = 44` confirms `x = 17`.
Principle: CoT Math Verification: Sign Errors in Transposition
An AI evaluates `(a + b)^2` for `a = 3, b = 4`: Step 1: `(a + b)^2 = a^2 + b^2` Step 2: `3^2 + 4^2 = 9 + 16 = 25`
What classic algebraic fallacy did the AI commit?
Division by zero.
Freshman's dream fallacy: omitting the cross term `2ab` (`(3 + 4)^2 = 49`, not `25`).
Sign inversion.
Rounding error.
Show the answer
B. Freshman's dream fallacy: omitting the cross term `2ab` (`(3 + 4)^2 = 49`, not `25`).
`(a + b)^2 = a^2 + 2ab + b^2`. With `a=3, b=4`, the true value is `7^2 = 49`, not `25`.
Principle: CoT Math Verification: Binomial Expansion
An AI solves: 'A store raises a $100 jacket by 20%, then discounts the new price by 20%. What is the final price?'
AI says: 'Raising by 20% and lowering by 20% cancel out, so the final price is $100.'
What is the actual final price, and why did the AI fail?
$100—the AI is right.
$96: 100 * 1.20 = $120, and 20% off $120 is $24, leaving $96.
$104.
$98.
Show the answer
B. $96: 100 * 1.20 = $120, and 20% off $120 is $24, leaving $96.
Percentage changes apply to different bases: `+20%` of `$100` is `+$20` (`$120`), while `-20%` of `$120` is `-$24`, leaving `$96`.
Principle: Quantitative Reasoning: Asymmetric Percentage Base